Radically Honest Blog

Mastering Value-Based Prioritization: a Guide to Maximizing Impact

As a product manager, you’re no stranger to the art of prioritization. You’ve likely scoured through a plethora of techniques, experimenting with a few along the way. 

While many prioritization methods gravitate towards appeasing stakeholders, considering timeframes, effort, and resources, this article hones in on a distinct approach: prioritizing based on the value derived from project completion.

In this exploration, we’ll tackle three key areas:

  • Demystifying Value-Based Prioritization: We’ll dive deep to understand why this concept is more than just another piece of corporate jargon dressed up in a fancy suit. It’s about the real substance beneath the buzzwords.
  • The Good, the Bad, and the Not-So-Ugly: Yes, there are undeniable benefits, but it’s not all sunshine and rainbows. We’ll candidly navigate through the potential pitfalls and challenges that might cross your path.
  • Tools of the Trade: There are no miracle cures here, but we do offer some practical, tested techniques that might not only save your day but could also revolutionize your next product meeting.

What is Value-Based Prioritization?

In the cutthroat world of business, while championing customer outcomes is the usual rallying cry, sometimes it pays to take a step back. Occasionally, it’s wise to recalibrate and consider the value to the business itself. 

This pragmatic approach doesn’t undercut customer needs; rather, it aligns them with business objectives. 

Enter value-based prioritization: a method that strategically benefits both the business and its customers, with a hint of shrewdness for good measure.

Navigating through value-based prioritization involves a careful balance of several factors:

  • Value: The crux lies in identifying projects that not only delight the customer but also contribute significantly to the business’s bottom line. The goal is to strike a balance where business growth and customer satisfaction are not at odds but in harmony.
  • Dependencies: When adjusting project priorities, consider the cascade effect on related initiatives. Lowering the priority of one project might disrupt others, revealing the interconnected nature of project ecosystems.
  • Risk: Evaluating risk versus return isn’t just about crunching numbers. It involves discerning whether the potential gains justify the risks. This assessment helps determine if a project is a calculated risk or a potential misstep.

Value-based prioritization’s role in Agile and Scrum methodologies is akin to a guiding principle. These methodologies thrive on adaptability and swift response to change, qualities that are enhanced by aligning efforts with the most valuable outcomes. 

Rather than merely executing tasks, Agile and Scrum teams guided by value-based prioritization ensure every sprint is a stride towards tangible value, not just motion for the sake of activity.

The Benefits of Value-Based Prioritization

Curious why value-based prioritization should be your go-to strategy? Let’s break it down:

  • Customer-Centric Focus: While value tends to relate specifically to business ROI, at the end of the day, it’s all about the customer. It’s about aligning your product roadmap and backlog with customer value. Instead of getting bogged down in feature creep, you’re constantly tuning into what really moves the needle for user satisfaction and retention. 
  • Efficiency and Productivity: Think of it as optimizing your sprint planning. You’re not just juggling tasks; you’re strategically aligning them for maximum impact with minimal resource burn. 
  • Better Decision Making: Here’s where you embrace your inner data geek. Value-based prioritization turns you into a metrics-driven decision-maker. You’re not just going by gut feeling; you’re leveraging KPIs and user data to guide your product decisions. Think of it like being the one in the room who knows the difference between a vanity metric and a North Star metric.
  • Flexibility and Adaptability: In product management, ‘pivot’ isn’t just a buzzword—it’s a survival skill. This approach equips you to adapt your product strategy swiftly in response to market shifts or user feedback without derailing your overall vision. 

The Downsides of Value-Based Prioritization

While value-based prioritization has its merits, it’s not without challenges:

  • Complexity in Defining Value: Pinpointing ‘value’ can be a subjective and contentious process. Aligning stakeholders on what constitutes value requires not only deep customer understanding but also a keen sense of business strategy.
  • Analysis Paralysis: Overemphasis on value can lead to decision-making gridlock. Continual evaluation and re-evaluation of options based on perceived value can significantly delay critical product decisions.
  • Short-term vs Long-term Value: Navigating the trade-off between immediate deliverables that show quick wins and long-term strategic initiatives requires a nuanced understanding of product lifecycle and market trends.
  • Resource Allocation Challenges: Effective resource distribution under this model demands rigorous prioritization. The risk is in misallocating resources to less impactful initiatives, potentially leading to suboptimal utilization of team capacity and budget.

What are some techniques useful for value-based prioritization?

Using value-based prioritization requires more than intuition—specific methodologies can guide the process. Here are a few:

MoSCoW Method: This method is essential for distinguishing between different levels of necessity. It involves categorizing tasks into ‘Must have,’ ‘Should have,’ ‘Could have,’ and ‘Won’t have.’ This approach helps in balancing critical deliverables with desirable but non-essential enhancements, ensuring the focus remains on delivering core value.

Putting together a MoSCoW-based table in Fibery is easy as 1-2-3
Putting together a MoSCoW-based table in Fibery is easy as 1-2-3

Kano Model: The Kano Model is a strategic tool for identifying customer preferences and expectations. It segments features into basic needs, performance features, and delighters. 

This technique is particularly useful for uncovering hidden opportunities that can elevate the user experience and differentiate the product in the market.

The Kano Model brings clarity and structure to your backlog
The Kano Model brings clarity and structure to your backlog

Weighted Scoring: This approach involves assigning numerical values to different features or tasks based on various criteria, such as impact on customers, business value, or complexity. 

The weighted scoring system provides a quantitative method to compare and prioritize features, allowing for data-driven decision-making.

Tasks organized by their weighted score in Fibery
Tasks organized by their weighted score in Fibery

The PM’s Hot Take

In value-based prioritization, the art is in balancing the scales between business impact and customer satisfaction. It’s a meticulous process of evaluating each project for its potential to drive organizational goals forward while simultaneously enhancing user experience.


Value-based prioritization stands as a key strategy in product management, deftly balancing business goals and customer satisfaction. 

As you navigate this complex terrain, remember that tools like those offered by Fibery can be instrumental in implementing these principles effectively. 

Fibery’s tools for product management offer the precision and flexibility needed to implement these strategies effectively. 

Delve deeper into the world of product management insights on the Fibery blog, where practical advice meets innovative thinking, helping you transform challenges into opportunities.

Psst... Wanna try Fibery? 👀

Infinitely flexible product discovery & development platform.